Monday, 24 November 2014

Non-Fiction Reading: Girl, Interrupted

The book I choose is titled, Girl, Interrupted and it is written by Susanna Kaysen. She documented her two year experience as a patient in a mental hospital in the late 1960's after a suicide attempt. She writes about the other girls who were admitted to the hospital, as well as the nurses and doctors who cared for her. The doctor who made the decision that she needed to spend time in the hospital did so throughout the process of only a very short interview and he claimed that she would be going away for two weeks. She ended up spending approximately two years there. Susanna explains what it was like to have all of her freedom taken away from her at a time when she should have had the most freedom in her young life. In her writing, it is obvious that she is a very intelligent and seemingly clearheaded person, which makes you wonder how she ever ended up in such a situation, but anyone can have mental health problems.

This book is definitely important, because some of the ways she describes mental illnesses is quite fascinating. It made me think of things in ways that I previously did not and that is always a good quality to have in a book. Considering that it is a book that documents one's own experiences and feelings, rather than being a historical account, there is definitely some bias.. For example, when she is explaining how quickly the doctor decided that she needed to go to a hospital, she managed to look at things from his point of view as well as her own. However, there will of course be some kind of bias in these types of books. It is unavoidable.

Girl, Interrupted has the potential to appeal to many different types of people, but I think that it is especially interesting to read as a seventeen year old girl. Susanna was just a year older than me when this took place and it is very strange to compare my life to hers. We are in such different places, but at the same time, I can relate to the ways she sometimes feels or the thoughts she has. The people she meets in the hospital are very real characters as well. They way they speak is realistic and she does not censor the things that they say at all. This means that there are some parts of the book that are a little inappropriate, but I think that it contributes to the story and that if she had not added that in, it would not be as realistic.

I enjoyed reading this and I wished that it was a longer book. I wanted to know more about the details of what happened to the other patients in the mental hospital after they recovered, or if they ever recovered, but there are so many things left unsaid. This is likely because what happened to them is unknown even to Susanna.

The best part of this book is that it left me with a lot to think about. As previously mentioned, I was sometimes able to relate to Susanna. That is probably what she intended when she wrote it. She wanted to make people question mental illness, since the definition of it is something that is always changing. An example she mentioned was homosexuality. It was something that a person could once be locked up in a mental hospital for, but that has changed over time and now it is accepted by most people. She also mentions that many disorders are just a matter of opinion, like "compulsive promiscuity", which she points out was more commonly diagnosed in women, and also "social contrariness". It is human nature to have a desire to categorize and put labels on things, but when it comes down to it, who is really to say what is considered usual or insane? How can we accurately define sanity when ideas are constantly changing? It is interesting to think about.

No comments:

Post a Comment